For Pia and Jenn Cutter, Provincetown has always been a place of contradictions. 

It was the setting of childhood summers spent with their father, a celebrated local artist whose talent was rivaled only by his devotion to alcohol. It was a place of beauty, creativity, and freedom. It was also a place marked by instability, complicated relationships, and memories neither sister fully escaped.

When their father dies, the sisters return expecting to settle his affairs and honor his memory. Instead, they find themselves confronting a growing series of questions that challenge everything they thought they knew about their family.

Locals begin attempting to erase them from their father’s history. Long-buried tensions rise to the surface. Then an unexpected stranger arrives with a claim that threatens to rewrite their family’s story entirely.

As grief gives way to suspicion, Pia and Jenn discover more messy secrets, more unanswered questions that they must navigate. But how?